This one arrived first; it is the Fresh Food Baby Feeder. This one is size "Large" I ordered it knowing my baby is older and would want more food. She can also handle slightly larger chunks (just incase the holes ended up being larger as well). On our first try I filled it with (homemade) butternut puree. When that ran out we switched to jarred baby food peas (all would be a stage 1 consistency). She LOVED it! The purees were a bit thin for this and it ended up being messy, BUT it worked and more food ended up in her than if I'd tried to spoon feed those to her. I've since used this with thicker homemade baby foods and it's worked wonderfully. This also came with a cover which will be handy we are on the go.
The next set to arrive was a set designed for pureed foods, but will also hold liquids. It has a slit on the bottom (in the picture it looks like it also has holes, but those are just bumps for texture). They really only let food/liquids out when baby sucks on it. I put beef broth in it for her to try. I refilled it 3 times. I think this would have been great a couple of months ago and I'll use it a bit now too. It came in a set of 2. My plan is to fill one with expressed milk and freeze it. This will be helpful for teething or if she's sick. I'd recommend it more for 4-6 month babies are just starting on foods, but we'll find it useful now too as she's not interested in a bottle or sippy cups.
I was super excited about this Kidsme feeder. It comes in a size large and you can purchase replacement sacs for it. The "sac" is a bit larger than the others and the holes are larger too. It'll be great for pieces of fresh fruit etc. I put homemade baby food in it for her first try. It was veggies and beef, and a fairly thick mix. None of it came out of the holes while I was filling it, but it seemed to come out nicely for her when she chewed on it. The mess was no bigger than it would have been had I tried to spoon feed her, but she was much happier eating this way. I do have one concern with this design. The hinged latch for securing it closed. It may hold up just fine, but if any part is going to give out on this I'm guessing that's the part. Just something to consider.
Bottom line? All of these were much easier to clean than the mesh ones we had been using. All of them are more versatile in the types of foods they hold. Baby LOVES them all. All but the Boon are also great for on the go. None of them hold more than a tablespoon, some less. Each one is slightly different and I do like having several as they need to be refilled throughout our meals.
*I'm and Amazon affiliate. If you shop through the above links and pictures (of products) I'll make a tiny bit of $$$ off of your purchase. It's a nice way to say "thank you for taking the time to type this up."